Amish Creamery Co
211 150th Ave | Madeira Beach, FL | (727) 397-8222

About Amish Creamery


Amish Creamery Company, Inc. was established September 6th, 2006, in Madeira Beach, Florida. Our product partner Big Olaf Ice Cream in Sarasota, FL, has been manufacturing Florida's finest homemade ice cream for 40 years.

We have many specialty products: meats, cheeses, Amish roll butter, scrapple, Lebanon bologna (sweet & regular), ring bologna, relishes, salsas, jarred fruits, jams, jellies, egg noodles, kettle potato chips, pretzels, fudge, Amish pies, Amish pastries, Amish (Kutztown) beverages: white birch beer, birch beer, root beer, diet black cherry, diet ginger ale, diet grape, diet orange, diet root beer, diet vanilla cream, 87 flavors of "Florida's finest homemade Amish ice cream." We have gift certificates available in: $5, $10, $20 and $25 denominations for someone looking for a special gift plus offer the opportunity for that special someone to personally shop at the Amish Creamery Company, Inc.

The Amish Community has a very strong influence in the way our store operates. We respect and honor their traditions, their values and the Amish beliefs. We believe it is important to our customers that our commitment to our Amish partners is much more than just a marketing ploy. It is a relationship that has been developed and nurtured for many years with friends and relatives.

We invite you stop in say hello and check out our great variety of Amish deli meats and cheeses, jar goods, old-fashioned sodas, fudge, many other Amish-made products -- all while you're enjoying Florida's finest homemade ice cream!